Social Media Examiner is picking a list of the top 10 social media blogs. They’ve printed a list of the 24 finalists. If you have a “social media” category in your Google Reader or some other RSS feed reader, it’s time to update your subscriptions.
Some time ago, I added one of my email addresses to the Papa John’s mailing list. The kids liked their pizza and wings for a while, and we had fun ordering online.
In recent months, I have read plenty of articles about John Schnatter that lead me to the conclusion that I really don’t feel like supporting Papa John’s with my business anymore. Here’s a piece in Forbes that gets into some of the details, and here’s one from Politico. I’ll leave it at that.
So what’s the marketing issue at play here? Well, aside from political blowback affecting sales: In recent weeks, I’ve repeatedly tried unsubscribing from the Papa John’s mailing list. The unsubscribe process didn’t work, the emails kept coming and I posted the following to the Papa John’s Facebook page:
Your emails will NOT allow me to unsubscribe. They are not coded properly. This is a violation of federal CAN-SPAM laws. Fix it.
Okay, a little inelegant, I suppose, but to their credit they responded quickly. Just two hours later, this was their reply:
To which I responded:
That will help me — but it doesn’t address the CAN-SPAM issue. I have been trying to unsubscribe for weeks, now. The “unsubscribe” link in the email takes me to an “email preferences” page. So far so good. I complete the form (including my reasoning: John Schnatter’s political views are blitheringly idiotic, as they are evidently a parroting of hyperpartisan demagoguery, so I will never buy PJ pizza again), click the “update” button and the page reloads; clearly doing nothing. And your emails keep coming. This is a clear violation of CAN-SPAM, which calls for “a visible and operable unsubscribe mechanism present in all emails.” Your unsubscribe mechanism is clearly not operable. Maybe Schnatter ought to worry less about 14 cents per pizza for employee health care and more about his own company running afoul of federal law, which can result in fines of hundreds of thousands of dollars.
(Okay, what can I say? It’s Tuesday and I’m cranky. I mean, how many emails hawking three-topping pizzas for $9.99 can I delete?)
No response yet on the Facebook page, but I’ll update this post if and when the conversation continues.
NOVEMBER 11 UPDATE: No response from Papa John’s, but I did get an email imploring me to add a second large pizza for $9.99. The email unsubscribe function clearly still doesn’t work.
NOVEMBER 12 UPDATE: No response from Papa John’s, but I did get an email introducing Papa john’s Chicken Poppers. The email unsubscribe function clearly still doesn’t work.
NOVEMBER 13 UPDATE: No response from Papa John’s, but I did get an email offering me 50% off an online order. The email unsubscribe function clearly still doesn’t work.
NOVEMBER 14 UPDATE: No response from Papa John’s, but I did get an email imploring me to buy a large 1-topping pizza for $6.99. The email unsubscribe function clearly still doesn’t work … Response from Papa John’s: “Craig, we’re sorry you are having issues unsubscribing from our email program. We’ve tested the links and found them operable. Please send us your email address via private message on Facebook so that we can look into the issue further. Thank you!” … My reply: ” I’ll be happy to forward the email somewhere so you can see how it’s not working; I’m less concerned about my email account specifically and more concerned about the links in the email not working generally.” … Their response: “Craig, that would be great if you could also forward the email you were having issues with so that our technical team can see what you are seeing in the email. Your email address is important so that we can troubleshoot log files as it pertains to your email address. This will help identify any potential issues with the unsubscribe process for not only you but for others. You may either contact us via private message on Facebook or send your email to onlinemarketing@papajohns.com. Thank you!”
Takeaway for marketers: You might want to double-check to see that your unsubscribe link — and the functionality on the page to which it directs users — is working. Just saying.
This infographic that’s making the rounds (it’s shown up several times in my Facebook, Twitter and G+ feeds) presents 36 rules of social media. It’s a little reminiscent of the 95 theses of The Cluetrain Manifesto, except they seem to come at some of the same issues from completely opposite directions.
For example: Social Media Rule #29 says, “People don’t want to shop where they socialize.” But Cluetrain Thesis #1 is simply: “Markets are conversations.”
So maybe people don’t want to shop where they socialize … but do they want to socialize where they shop? (Malls would suggest: Hell, yeah!) And if so, what are the implications for brands online?
Here’s another one: Cluetrain thesis #74: “we are immune to advertising. Just forget it.” Doesn’t quite dovetail with Rule #25: “The only way to scale word of mouth: paid advertising.”
So does advertising work, or doesn’t it?
Sorry, I don’t have any answers. I just find it interesting that when it comes to business wisdom, it’s often style that trumps substance. Advertising works. Advertising doesn’t work. The substance of the position doesn’t matter; say it with the proper style, though, and you’ll convince plenty of people that you’re right.
Takeaway for marketers (and for non-marketers, too): Style vs. substance. Sorta sound like life, not just marketing, dunnit?
These days, Anthony Weiner notwithstanding, a Twitter account is as important as a Facebook account, town halls and kissing babies for a politician. It’s communication with constituents — and anyone who hasn’t figured it out yet needs to. Fast.
What would the world of social media and marketing articles and blog posts be without a bunch of resolutions for 2013? Here’s a links roundup:
Marketer’s New Year’s Resolutions For 2013 (CMO.com)
Social media resolutions for 2013 (Social Madness)
2013 Online Marketing Resolutions: Do This – Not That (Empower Network)
Top 2012 Social Media Resolutions: Share Less, With Fewer People (Mashable)
Your Top PR, Marketing and Social Media Resolutions for 2013 (Cision Blog)
3 Social Media New Years Resolutions You Should Make for 2013 (Advise Media)
5 Online Marketing Resolutions to Make in 2013 (Business 2 Community)
6 Social Media Resolutions Your Business Should Keep in 2013 (Influence/Agents)
Seven social media resolutions for nonprofit professionals (Charity Village)
